Grades 3–5 · Lesson 2 · 40 min
Loud Is Not the Same as Brave
Featured: Trey the Trumpet · SEL trait: Courage & self-control · CASEL: Self-Management
Objective
Students will distinguish between reacting loudly and responding with control, and name one self-control strategy.
Materials
- Story: Chapter 2 — Trey and the Echo Cliffs
- Scenario cards (conflict at recess, wrong answer, being teased)
- Breathing poster
Lesson Steps
- Read Chapter 2 and chart what Trey tried first and what worked.
- Teach 'horn breath': in for 4, out slow for 8, like sustaining a note.
- In pairs, read scenario cards and plan a loud reaction vs. a controlled response.
- Act out both versions and discuss the different outcomes.
- Each student writes their go-to strategy on a sticky note for the class wall.
Activities
GameEcho Cliffs
Teacher plays a rhythm at a set volume; students echo it at exactly that volume. Volume control, not speed, earns the point.
Assessment
exit ticket: Describe a moment this week when a controlled response would have helped.
Standards Alignment
ASCA Mindsets & Behaviors
Demonstrate self-discipline and self-control
Missouri School Counseling
Understand and manage personal emotions and behaviors
DESE Fine Arts — Music
Develop and refine musical techniques and expression
Differentiation
Give a pre-written strategy menu for students who struggle to generate one.
Home Connection
Family prompt: practice horn breath together before homework.
Printable Worksheet
Worksheet: 'React or Respond' — two-column scenario sort.
Tip: use your browser's Print button (Ctrl/Cmd + P) for a clean printable lesson plan and worksheet.