← Brass unitGrades 9–12

Grades 9–12 · Lesson 4 · 50 min

Mediation and the Middle Voice

Featured: Bart the Baritone · SEL trait: Conflict resolution · CASEL: Relationship Skills

Objective

Students will run a structured mediation and evaluate outcomes against both parties' stated needs.

Materials

  • Story: Chapter 7 — Bart Between the Voices
  • Formal mediation protocol
  • Observation rubric

Lesson Steps

  1. Read Chapter 7 and analyze the cost of conflict avoidance.
  2. Review a formal mediation protocol including neutrality and confidentiality.
  3. Run mediations in fours: two parties, one mediator, one observer with a rubric.
  4. Observers report on neutrality and paraphrase accuracy.
  5. Discuss when mediation is inappropriate and referral is required.

Activities

DiscussionWhen Not to Mediate

Identify situations (safety, power imbalance, abuse) that require adult referral rather than peer mediation.

Assessment

rubric: Observed mediation performance.

  • Maintains neutrality throughout
  • Paraphrases each party accurately
  • Surfaces needs beneath positions
  • Recognizes when to refer instead of mediate

Standards Alignment

ASCA Mindsets & Behaviors

ASCA·B-SS5

Demonstrate ethical decision-making and social responsibility

Missouri School Counseling

MO Counseling·MO-SE-5

Develop interpersonal and relationship skills

DESE Fine Arts — Music

DESE Music·MU:Re9

Apply criteria to evaluate musical work

Differentiation

Rotate the observer role first for students building confidence.

Home Connection

Share the referral criteria with a family member.

Printable Worksheet

Printable: mediation protocol and observation rubric.

Tip: use your browser's Print button (Ctrl/Cmd + P) for a clean printable lesson plan and worksheet.

Open printable worksheet →