Grades 9–12 · Lesson 4 · 50 min
Mediation and the Middle Voice
Featured: Bart the Baritone · SEL trait: Conflict resolution · CASEL: Relationship Skills
Objective
Students will run a structured mediation and evaluate outcomes against both parties' stated needs.
Materials
- Story: Chapter 7 — Bart Between the Voices
- Formal mediation protocol
- Observation rubric
Lesson Steps
- Read Chapter 7 and analyze the cost of conflict avoidance.
- Review a formal mediation protocol including neutrality and confidentiality.
- Run mediations in fours: two parties, one mediator, one observer with a rubric.
- Observers report on neutrality and paraphrase accuracy.
- Discuss when mediation is inappropriate and referral is required.
Activities
DiscussionWhen Not to Mediate
Identify situations (safety, power imbalance, abuse) that require adult referral rather than peer mediation.
Assessment
rubric: Observed mediation performance.
- Maintains neutrality throughout
- Paraphrases each party accurately
- Surfaces needs beneath positions
- Recognizes when to refer instead of mediate
Standards Alignment
ASCA Mindsets & Behaviors
Demonstrate ethical decision-making and social responsibility
Missouri School Counseling
Develop interpersonal and relationship skills
DESE Fine Arts — Music
Apply criteria to evaluate musical work
Differentiation
Rotate the observer role first for students building confidence.
Home Connection
Share the referral criteria with a family member.
Printable Worksheet
Printable: mediation protocol and observation rubric.
Tip: use your browser's Print button (Ctrl/Cmd + P) for a clean printable lesson plan and worksheet.